Rourke wanted the script to reflect Fallon's background, such as the conditions of the Irish Catholics, "They're not unlike the conditions of the blacks in the south in America before the civil rights movement of the sixties," said Rourke and sectarianism. This was part of the play or pay deal. But then I've always liked his work.
A Prayer for Funerals
He's spent months perfecting an Irish accent. He really looks the part. Hodges worked on the script too. This last one he does for self-preservation. In the original story he went on killing people, which I thought wouldn't work for us. It made him just another hoodlum.
Originally Inseminoid music composer John Scott had composed the film but was fired due to creative differences from the producers and they hired Bill Conti to finish the score. Tony Earnshaw recalls in his book "Made in Yorkshire" that another film version of the novel was planned in the s to film in Leeds the city where the original book was set starring Lee Marvin and directed and written by Edward Dmytryk.
Photos of the two men looking at Leeds locations for the film are shown in Earnshaw's book. For the priest character, Hodges said, "Priests can be so sanctimonious on the screen, and I didn't want a Barry Fitzgerald or a Bing Crosby. I wanted him to be more a working-class priest, a rough diamond. Alan Bates was cast as the villain. This man in A Prayer for the Dying is so caught up in his own evil that he's lost perspective, though in a very pecular way he has his own morality.
He won't hurt old ladies, for example, and he takes genuine pride in what he does: The film is about conscience, but there's a macabre wit and a heightened sense of style in it. Hodges said he delivered his cut of the film to Goldwyn in March and the company, without consulting him, reedited it and replaced its musical score. A Prayer for the Dying has a mixed reaction. Some liked Rourke's performance. Others put fault in his Irish accent. Other critics thought Bob Hoskins was miscast in his portrayal of the priest. Hodges tried to take his name off as he felt Sam Goldwyn studio had drastically altered the film.
He called it, "a piece of schlock for the American market divested of any kind of poetry or subtlety. What they have done to the movie makes quite certain the audience will never understand him, either. I got no reply to either one. They said it was too late to take my name off the prints and all the promotional materials. But they had shown the film to others earlier. Obviously, they just didn't want to deal with my problems.
I was making a small movie that I hoped would make things clearer about what's going on in Northern Ireland. He wanted to turn it into a big commercial extravaganza-type thing. Goldwyn said "I won't say the experience of making the movie was terribly happy, but it's a good picture and he [Rourke] is very good in it.
There were rumours that there was going to be a director's cut of the film as Mike Hodges had a critical hit film Croupier. That release was going to be by MGM. Both region 1 and 2 have the original theatrical release. Film 87 Mike Hodges express his dislike on the Studio cut.
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia. He may be describing a man having carnal relations with a corpse, but the tenor of his writing remains appropriate for a treatise on federal estate tax law. There are themes and leitmotifs swirling around A Prayer for the Dying.tcpassessment.com/images/como-puede/3487.php
Prayer for the Dying
Questions are raised about good and evil and faith. The trouble with a book like this, marked by its brevity and terseness, is that it only really gets around to raising these questions, rather than expounding upon them or — gasp — attempting an answer or two. In any event, this is a novel that I certainly respect, from an aesthetic standpoint, if no other. On the other hand, it is certainly not a novel I enjoyed. View all 3 comments. Jan 19, Mike Puma rated it really liked it Shelves: Did you know you surv The paperback cover carries a blurb: View all 6 comments.
Mar 02, Jen rated it it was amazing Shelves: It will grab you by the neck and pull you under. I want that to be my whole review but I'm a wordy bitch, so here goes: When things go bad, how do you know they don't go bad because of you and not just in spite of you or your efforts? And when things go bad, so bad that you aren't sure any more what goodness is or was, does that first question even matter? And if it doesn't matter, why make an effort? If questions like these make you want to steer the kayak of yo It is short. If questions like these make you want to steer the kayak of your mind closer to the vortex of this story, then go ahead.
View all 32 comments. Jacob Hansen is a civil war veteran and the sheriff, pastor and undertaker of the small town of Friendship. On an ordinary summer day people begin to fall ill, first one, then more. Jacob watches his beloved town unravel as diphtheria takes hold while a fire simultaneously bears down on Friendship. He struggles to balance his various roles in the town, as well as that of husband and father, as he faces these twin challenges.
There is a very calm, subtle, matter-of-fact tone to this book which so Jacob Hansen is a civil war veteran and the sheriff, pastor and undertaker of the small town of Friendship. There is a very calm, subtle, matter-of-fact tone to this book which somehow still manages to convincingly convey the mounting despair that Jacob feels. It is really a masterful work.
My first experience with Stewart O'Nan and not entirely sure what to expect. My knowledge of him is sparse: He grew up here in Pittsburgh and went on to write about the Red Sox with Stephen King and is often compared to Flannery O'Connor, Edgar Allan Poe and Shirley Jackson, all of which piqued my interest and helped convince me to pick up a book of his. Postbellum Friendship, Wisconsin - Jacob Hansen is the town's constable, undertaker and pastor as his town is threatened by two simultaneous dan My first experience with Stewart O'Nan and not entirely sure what to expect.
Postbellum Friendship, Wisconsin - Jacob Hansen is the town's constable, undertaker and pastor as his town is threatened by two simultaneous dangers: His job is to keep the peace in the town as the disease destroys lives around him and make the right decisions, always; though which decision is always the right , the best? Written from a second person perspective a point-of-view I have not been a fan of in the past, though it clearly serves an incredible power here , the reader becomes Jacob as he tries to make the best choices for his family and for his town, all with the additional threat of insanity tickling at his brain.
This was a wonderful surprise, though not suggested for the weak-stomached or easily sensitive. It's a quick read easy to read on a lazy summer Sunday afternoon , mostly because of O'Nan's writing and how hard it is to put it down for more than a few minutes. I wanted to know how it ended and when I did I wanted even more. It's rare that a book hits me like that, so clearly I'm bumping more of O'Nan's books up to the top of my list. Nov 05, Darlene rated it it was amazing.
This very bleak but beautifully written novel novella really by Stewart O'Nan takes place in the time period following the end of the Civil War in Friendship, Wisconsin. Jacob Hansen has just returned from the war and is struggling to fit back into the town that he loves. Jacob is Friendship's sheriff, undertaker and pastor; and he takes all of those roles very seriously.
He is married to Marta and they have a baby girl, Amelia; the two are the anchor in Jacob's life. The story is told through This very bleak but beautifully written novel novella really by Stewart O'Nan takes place in the time period following the end of the Civil War in Friendship, Wisconsin. The story is told through Jacob's eyes but is told in the second person This story begins on a very hot July day.
Jacob is making his rounds as sheriff when he is told that a dead man has been found in the woods outside of town. Thinking it may be one of the many soldiers who are not yet aware that the war has ended and wander around trying to find their regiment, he heads out to have a look. Not only does he end up discovering a deceased soldier, but he also comes across a delirious woman, lying in a field and burning up with fever. He manages to get the soldier's body back to town and delivers the very ill woman to the town's doctor, Doc.
What started out as a hot, still, end of July day begins what will be a nightmare for Jacob, Doc and the town of Friendship. Doc confirms that the deceased soldier and the seriously ill woman have contracted diphtheria and there is no available cure. The discovery of this epidemic is only the first test of faith that Jacob will endure. Jacob believes that the right thing to do is to put the town under quarantine but Doc is afraid that panic and hysteria will occur so the two decide to wait and see what happens. Unfortunately, this turns out to be the wrong judgement call.
Within the matter of a few short days, many of the town's residents are sick or have already succumbed to diphtheria And this is just the beginning of the trials that Jacob will face. He also receives word that a fast moving wildfire has started in a neighboring town; and with the hot, dry weather and the parched vegetation, the wildfire is headed for Friendship. What should Jacob do? Does he force a quarantine of his town's residents, knowing a fire is headed straight for them? Or does he allow them to flee, knowing they will spread diphtheria to unsuspecting people?
In a story that plays out in ways that seems reminiscent of the Biblical stories of Abraham and Job, Jacob is faced over and over with difficult..
Prayer for the Dying # 2
When reading this story, you couldn't help but ask yourself just how much one man could handle without completely breaking? Jacob was a man haunted by his experiences in the war and battling his conscience over the decisions he had made regarding his beloved town and its citizens. He so much wanted to be a good and righteous man His actions exemplified all that is good in human beings and yet And this story was ultimately about that age old struggle that human beings face..
The truth, I believe, After all, are there really any decisions that can really be seen as 'black' or 'white' in this world which seems so many shades of 'gray'? O'Nan wrote an amazing novel that explored some powerful spiritual and philosophical questions and he accomplished this through a completely credible and sympathetic character. His beautiful language appealed to my senses in a way that I have only occasionally experienced while reading.. An example of this was a moving scene which occurred after Jacob had prepared his baby girl for burial. When thinking about her death, he said The crab apple bows.
The sun's going down and it's all in shadow. The dirt in the corner is dried and cracked, and ant struggling across it, carrying another ant bent double. Glance over the fences on both sides; there's no one. You press your hand to the cool earth as if spreading on her chest, cover your eyes. What do you see when you remember her? Marta bathing her in the tub, a hand cupping her head.
Playing on the floor, holding her above you and watching her tiny feet kick. She never said a word. O'Nan used beautiful language throughout the story to create this stark and very powerful story. Reading this novel reminded me of just why Stewart O'Nan is one of my favorite authors. View all 10 comments. Jun 16, Christy rated it it was amazing Shelves: This book is mind-blowingly awesome. Weaving together scraps of the protagonist's Civil war memories with his current situation of disease and raging fire, the book grabs the reader for a terrifying ride and does not let go, not even after the story has ended.
Nov 13, Diane Barnes rated it it was amazing. I finished this book last night, but tired as I was, could not sleep for thinking about it. There are several lifetimes packed into these pages. Jacob is the sherriff, undertaker and minister to the small town of Friendship, Wisconsin. The Civil War has been over for 6 years, but his memories of the dead and dying persist. His life is a good one, with a loving wife and 6 month old daughter, the respect of his townspeople, and a sense of responsibility for their care and protection.
Then a dip I finished this book last night, but tired as I was, could not sleep for thinking about it. Then a diptheria epidemic breaks out. In the midst of the dying, fire threatens the town. This book starts out almost idyllic in it's portrayal of a summer day, and quickly descends into the complete hell that the disease and the fire create. Jacob's sense of responsibility and need to do the right thing for his family and town make it even worse for him. His realization in the last pages left me gasping with sympathy for this man, whose need to do the right thing would haunt him for the rest of his life.
This book goes on my lifetime favorite list. The single criteria for this list is a book that stays in my mind and heart, and whose characters remain a part of me. En verdad fue muy interesante ver como todo empieza bien y se va desmoronando, hace que no puedas dejar el libro. Buena historia narrada de una forma peculiar. Solo al final logras comprender el verdadero origen de sus traumas y fanatismos.
Jacob Hansen has recently stepped out of the Civil War and into juggling several roles that of preacher, sheriff and undertaker in the small town of Friendship, Wisconsin. However, Friendship soon finds itself trapped in a Catch, where they should stay quarantined due to a diphtheria epidemic, yet should be fleeing from the great incoming fire. Jacob struggles with the past horrors in his present circumstance, his responsibility to the town versus his concern for his wife and infant child, and the desire to do good while the choice to do so seems to be slipping away.
Prayer for the Dying - Prayers - Catholic Online
While many would argue this is basically the same as first-person, I usually take this move as an indication of the need for distance in the narrative, a twist that will yank and contort further away as the ending nears. The ending is boring and predictable, too. He flipped this picture over where it was nothing but threads and said he felt like this was the part he was seeing right now, but that somehow, maybe even naively, he still trusted God to one day have it make sense.
I can think my way through how the parts work, maybe feel smart that I sussed out how the tension and dissonance plays in, but the book has no heartbeat. One star, but reaching higher. May 23, Hannah rated it it was amazing Shelves: This is likely my favorite novel of all time.
I'm currently on my fourth time through, and it gets better every time.
2. Pray for God’s peace.
I've seen a lot of reviews that address the second person narrative in this text. Apparently, some find it difficult to follow. However, I did not. In fact, I found it to be one of the strengths of O'Nan's writing. It is not truly second person - rather, first person perspective using second person pronouns. Instead of "I", he uses "you" I think this is particularly effective as This is likely my favorite novel of all time. Instead of "I", he uses "you" I think this is particularly effective as the reader is immersed in the perspective of a protagonist who has to continuously talk himself into sanity with questionable success.
After all, this is how we often talk ourselves into things - by addressing ourselves in second person. This narrative demonstrates sanity as a continuum and not the dichotomy that the terms we use sanity and insanity would suggest. It raises more questions than it answers - in the spirit of the biblical story of Job. Unlike common interpretations of Job, it is not a story of hope and, like the story of Job, it is questionably a story of faith and the reader's interpretation is largely dependent on the set of beliefs one holds when approaching the text.
I also appreciate O'Nan's restraint from using a neat denouement. A story that is so dark, bleak, and painfully honest cannot and should not be wrapped up in a pretty way. Que se ve afectado por una epidemia. Mar 24, Lisa Harmonybites rated it it was amazing Recommends it for: Recommended to Lisa Harmonybites by: This is the kind of novel you end a little stunned. I have a friend whose literary tastes I greatly respect, a gifted writer herself, who raved about O'Nan to me--this is the first novel of his I've ever read, but won't be the last. She actually gave me her copy of this book when I mentioned I couldn't find it in stores.
It was recommended in a horror recommendation list, and my friend expressed surprise it would be thought of that way. Having now read it I understand what she means. Inside a blu This is the kind of novel you end a little stunned. But this reads more like literary fiction in its prose style, and there's not a whiff of the supernatural in content. The monster roaming the small Wisconsin town of Friendship, Wisconsin in isn't a vampire, a werewolf or zombie--it's diphtheria. This story is in the rare second person, through the perspective of Jacob Hansen, a union civil war veteran who acts as the town's sheriff, pastor and undertaker.
I have another writer friend who considers second person a gimmick and unbearable to read. The thing is I can't imagine this story written any other way. Telling this story through first person or third would be too normal, sound too down home. But something about that second person voice tells us there's something a bit askew from the beginning. Second person, especially given it's always in present tense, almost always sounds lyrical.
Somehow, O'Nan's prose is more muscular than that. It's the kind often described as "spare. It comes across as more stark than spare considering the tone and the short novel--I'd say it's no more than about 60, words--reads very quickly; I read it in almost one sitting. The novel is harrowing. That deceptively simple seeming style doesn't spare you the horror of the epidemic or how it unravels Jacob's mind, heart and spirit. Indeed, there's an aspect to the book that might be too much for many, that pushed it over the line and some might find over the top into the grotesque, and for me saved only by the restraint of the writing.
I think the blurb from the Wall Street Journal review got it right: As eloquent as it is unsettling.
- Talisman: Sacred Cities, Secret Faith.
- A Prayer for the Dying by Stewart O'Nan.
- Prayers for the Dying;
- Two Preludes, Op. 39.
May 22, Lizzie rated it it was amazing Recommends it for: Recommended to Lizzie by: You know it's not going to be a feel-good book of the year when the credit page says "The author would like to acknowledge his great dept to Michael Levy, whose Wisconsin Death Trip inspired this book. I like the characters and I fear for them. I'm thinking about what else to say about why I liked this so much.
It starts out slow and builds fast, lik You know it's not going to be a feel-good book of the year when the credit page says "The author would like to acknowledge his great dept to Michael Levy, whose Wisconsin Death Trip inspired this book.
It starts out slow and builds fast, like a train or a fire or an epidemic, all featured in the book. I'm not sure yet. Less than a week ago a dear friend died, and I'm feeling raw with grief about her and about her husband and how awful it would be to lose one's beloved spouse, so the images of home and marriage and safety really resonated with me. Because the truth is, there is no safety, really, and even if we aren't in a village where everyone is dying of an incurable disease with a fire bearing down on us Jun 20, Nikki rated it liked it Shelves: This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers.
To view it, click here. In the late s a book of old photographs called Wisconsin Death Trip was rather popular in the upper Midwest. The most shocking of the photographs to our modern sensibilities were those of dead children in their coffins. I chose to read the book because it received rave reviews from some people on the DorothyL mystery list, but I wouldn't call it a mystery. It is almost a horror novel, although not in any supernat In the late s a book of old photographs called Wisconsin Death Trip was rather popular in the upper Midwest. It is almost a horror novel, although not in any supernatural sense.
One could also call it an examination of post-traumatic stress disorder. The book is written using the second person singular, an unusual style, as if perhaps the reader is being forcibly put in the place of the protagonist. He is a Civil War veteran who fills three jobs in the small town of Friendship, Wisconsin: When the book opens, he is summoned to pick up a body in the woods behind a local farm, and finds that it is a fellow veteran unknown to him who is on the tramp and appears to have been murdered.
But his investigation is put aside when diphtheria appears in town. He and the town doctor must decide how to handle the threat of an epidemic, and they decide wrongly. As if things weren't bad enough, a huge forest fire is raging in the region and keeps getting closer to Friendship. It's not far into the book before you realize there will be no happy ending here.
There really was a great fire in northeastern Wisconsin in at the same time as, though unrelated to, the Chicago fire , and anyone who has walked through a Midwestern cemetery from that era has doubtless seen evidence of diphtheria epidemics. Although I can't say I enjoyed this book, it was well-written and a study of one man's descent into madness in the face of disaster. It would be interesting to read this in conjunction with Geraldine Brooks 's Year of Wonders , with which it has both similarities and differences.
May 05, Michael rated it it was amazing Shelves: I'm very glad that I read Wisconsin Death Trip before reading this novel. It's like a macabre vignette from the earlier book. O'Nan has a spare style that lends itself well to the isolation and simple lifestyle in Friendship. As people start to fall sick from diptheria, you get the impression that the world really IS ending.
Even though there were other towns close by, the community of Friendship or any community from the time period was so close-knit that nothing will remain when everything d I'm very glad that I read Wisconsin Death Trip before reading this novel. Even though there were other towns close by, the community of Friendship or any community from the time period was so close-knit that nothing will remain when everything disintegrates. Me ha costado entrar casi medio libro. Pero una vez dentro te atrapa. Es deprimente de cojones, pero es de esos que recuerdas.
Jan 10, Laurie rated it it was ok. First of all, Eeeww!! When he gets out of the lake with his shovel and heads back to Friendship to be with the ones he loves. Does that mean he is going to properly bury everyone in Friendship because he loves the town and the people so much. Or, does it mean he is going to dig up his wife and daughter and play house with them again? I kind of take it to mean both, but more-so the being with his family. He knows what he is doing First of all, Eeeww!! He knows what he is doing on some level because he mentions that he should have used more fluid when his wife's jaw starts to show or droop or whatever.
How nasty and sinky!
And, he even bathes her - gross. I looked up some information on diphtheria and not everyone is susceptible to it, so Jacob probably was the carrier and infected all those people.
I didn't find anything that mentioned that the infection can cause people to go crazy, though, so that does not seem to be related to the disease. By burning the elderly woman alive in her nephew's or whatever relation's house, and having to kill the cow, the cat, etc. Seems to me that we're led to think he's already troubled, at a minimum, seeing as how he won't ride a horse and the way he takes such painstaking pride in his work as the undertaker. Seems to me like he considers that his primary job and being the town preacher is secondary.
We just experience so much more detail of him taking care of the dead than preaching. And what was up with the statement about the war guy that he fed and when he buried him Jacob had to make sure his shirt sleeves were down so that people wouldn't see the strips of skin missing? Is he a cannibal, too? I'm guessing it was written that way to impress that driven to extreme's, anyone is capable of anything. If anything, it made me more detached from the story. Aug 29, Bryan Mulholland rated it it was amazing. I can't write too much without giving spoilers; so, I will have to be vague.
Related Prayer for the Dying
Copyright 2019 - All Right Reserved