Lists with This Book. This book is not yet featured on Listopia. Jun 10, Inna rated it it was amazing. Another brilliant book by Etkind, where he analyzes a special kind of colonization - a case where the elite is colonizing its own territory and people with help of the state, but itself is vulnerable to a change of status due to the fragility of the modes of differentiation.
For example, somebody losing social status due to one reason or another would be treated as colonized.epay.vg/top-phone-locate-tool-oneplus-6.php
Internal Colonization: Russia's Imperial Experience - Alexander Etkind - Google Книги
The problem was that the difference between colonizers and colonized in a case like Russia, where both belong to the same Another brilliant book by Etkind, where he analyzes a special kind of colonization - a case where the elite is colonizing its own territory and people with help of the state, but itself is vulnerable to a change of status due to the fragility of the modes of differentiation. The problem was that the difference between colonizers and colonized in a case like Russia, where both belong to the same ethnicity and the same culture was a matter of education and appearance bearded versus shaved and that could have easily changed.
Etkind claims that after external colonization of the North became impossible due to scarcity of furs, Russia had to turn to agriculture and thus to treat its own peasants as colonized subjects. That entailed cultural differentiation between the elite and the peasantry, emphasis on real or invented foreignness of the elite and serfdom which, according to Etkind, was not overall profitable he claims that grain export from the areas of mass serfdom was unprofitable, since these were too far from the ports , but was upheld as part of the political arrangement within the state.
Etkind also claims that this arrangement was supported by orientalist views of the exotic peasantry and, surprisingly, by the Russian literature which, due to its humanistic impulse, attracted all kinds of people and created a sort of unity within the Russian empire, an empire constantly widening its borders and its orientalist views. Even though, as Etkind points out, the enserfed were largely ethnically Russian.
Overall Etkind claims that in Russia the normal experience of colonialism was as both a colonizer a peasant sent to fight in the Caucasus and a colonized the same peasant in relation to Russian government and its representatives. Similar examples would be rebellious students sent to the North as colonized subjects but there working in the local administration and acting as colonizers towards the local populations.
Or a Polish noble acting as a colonizer towards the peasants, but sent to Siberia as a political exile. View all 6 comments. Oct 01, Alisha rated it really liked it Shelves: This is a dense, informative book.
The joy of reading this volume is the variety of sources on which Etkind draws. His work is complex and he discusses a vast array of topics from a number of theoretical frameworks. By contextualizing the internal colonization of Russia into the broader discourse on imperialism, Etkind makes a convincing case that Russia's relationship with i This is a dense, informative book.
Internal Colonization: Russia's Imperial Experience
By contextualizing the internal colonization of Russia into the broader discourse on imperialism, Etkind makes a convincing case that Russia's relationship with its contiguous subjects were not so different from Britain's far-flung ones, for example. Indeed, Etkind's thoughts, carefully interwoven with diverse source material offer a convincing alternative to the notion of Russian exceptionalism.
Though not a scholar of history or cultural studies, I would posit that this volume is a must-read for anyone who studies colonization from either of these perspectives. I would say that the author provides his readers with a very intriguing perspective of Russian colonial literature and history. What I like the most is the fact that the book inspires for exploration and learning. And even if you think that you are already prepared for another intellectual challenge, the author surprises you with new facts and his very unusual and intelligent interpretation of them.
Get A Copy
I never finished this one. It will be essential reading for students of Russian history and literature and for anyone interested in the literary and cultural aspects of colonization and its aftermath. His most recent book is Internal Colonization: Russia's Imperial Experience The Non-Traditional Orient Chapter 1.
- The Prophet.
- Commonsense Approaches to Alzheimers.
- To Die or Not to Die: Ten Tricks to Getting Better Medical Care.
Less than One and Double Chapter 2. Writing from Scratch Chapter 3.
See a Problem?
Chasing Rurik Chapter 4. To Colonize Oneself Chapter 5. Barrels of Fur Part 3.
- Prélude, No. 1 from Larlésienne, Suite 1.
- Ab Imperio?
- My Sisters Keeper.
- Internal Colonization: Russia's Imperial Experience | Polity | Brands | Wiley.
- Internal Colonization: Russia's Imperial Experience by Alexander Etkind.
Empire of the Tsars Chapter 6. Occult Instability Chapter 7. Disciplinary Gears Chapter 8. Internal Affairs Part 4. To purchase short term access, please sign in to your Oxford Academic account above. Don't already have an Oxford Academic account? Oxford University Press is a department of the University of Oxford. It furthers the University's objective of excellence in research, scholarship, and education by publishing worldwide.
Sign In or Create an Account. Close mobile search navigation Article navigation. A lexander E tkind. You do not currently have access to this article. You could not be signed in.
Related Internal Colonization: Russias Imperial Experience
Copyright 2019 - All Right Reserved